Session 3 With or Without God - by Gretta Vosper
why the way we live is more important than what we believe
Opening Meditation
"Whether non-theistic religious gatherings can thrive and survive is anyone's guess. We are in the midst of a great experiement. I fervently believe that we need to see that experiment through to the end, giving our all to the creation of communities of "faith" that celebrate the communal nature of life and challenge us to engage in right relationship with self, others, and the planet." ... p356

The Man Who Couldn't - Dorothy Reynar
At one time or another, we all make mistakes. One day at the mall a woman said she wanted to get some baked goods, so her husband suggested she go into the bakery while he parked the car closer.

When he entered the bakery he thought he saw his wife leaning over a bread display. He sneaked up hehind her and gave her a big hug. The woman who stiffened and turned around was a total stranger. Embarrassed, he apologized and explained his mistake. But she smiled and said "don't be sorry. a nice hug never hurt anyone."

I'm intrigued by the saying on the cover of Gretta Vospers book: "The way we live is more important than the way we believe."

Both sides of the brain, the left or "reasoning" side and the right or "creative" side are interrelated through the corpus callosum. sometimes both sides work cooperatively and sometimes one side holds sway over the other, but they are always, somehow, in tandem, taking Vosper's saying one more step I would say that the way we live is what we believe and what we believe is the way we live, even though both sides of this truth may be difficult to discern.

Now let's turn to "the man who couldn't". One busy day at the Alberta Hospital Ponoka, I was interrupted aby an urgent call from a psychiatrist in our Outpatient department regarding a distressed couple. The 28 year old husbands was a pastor in a fundamentalist church where he preached God's authority and the literal interpretation of the Bible to his congregation of born-again Christians. His wife, age 25, was the organist.

They had been married four years and had never consummated the marriage because he experienced erectile dysfunction. although they loved one another and longed to have children it was physically impossible for him to maintain an erection. This was before the days of Viagra and modern sex therapy. The couple had been seen by various professionals who were unable to determine the physical or emotional source of the problem.

The psychiatrist heard their story and then said, "I'm afraid I can't help you but i know someone who can. Dr. Crouse is a clinical psychologist and I"m going to ask her to give you a Rorshach."

The doctor told me that the husband was in such distress we might have to admit him to a psychiatric unit. so the doctor brought John (not his real name) to my office and said, "This is Dr. Crouse. She will give you a Rorschach".

The Rorschach is a diagnostic personality test. John would look at a series of 10 inkblots and tell me what he saw there. The test would explore John's level of conscious and subconscious awareness, revelaing how he saw himself and others and the world around him. Hopefully, it would bring to light some of John's hopes, fears and motivations. I would interpret the results and pass them on to the psychiatrist to become part of Joh's treatment plan.

John seemed anxious and fearful, trying to maintain control. He asked "Are you a Christian?" "Trying to be one," I answered. He seemed perplexed by my answer but came in and sat down. "I'm awfully nervous" he stated, "and the psychiatrist says you're vbery busy, so let's get started". "Of course", I said, "I'm going to show you some inkblots and I'd like you to tell me what you see there, what they look like to you." His hands were shaking but he took each card in turn. He was very cooperative, describing in detail what he saw. Overall, it was an excellent Rorschach.

As we moved to the second phase where he elaborated on what he had seen, he asked, "how am I doing?" "You're doing just find, "I reassured him." Are you sure this will help?" "Absolutely, I know it will help."

When we finished I said, "Well, John, that's it. Thank you very much." "Is that all? That's it?" he asked. He stood up, and looking enormously relieved said, "I don't know how to thank you. I'm so grateful for your help. God bless you." We shook hands and he left. I suddenly realized that I had neglected to tell him that the Rorschach is just a personality test. He had mistakenly perceived it as a treatment or even a cure for his erectile dysfunction.

The next day the psychiatrist stopped by my office and asked, "Dorothy, what did you do to that minister yesterday?" "I gave him the Rorschach you requested. "I know that, but what else did you do to him?" "Nothing, why?"

"Well, he phoned this moring to say that evberthing is working fine. They were overjoyed to report that the marriage was consummated and celebrated. They had high praise for Dr. Crouse, this wonderful woman whom God had chosen to give John her unusual inkbot treatement."

Three months later they phoned with the news that they were expecting their first baby.